Jump to the main content
GigaGone
Search

Search GigaGone

How to Choose an External Drive for Backups

By Published Topic: Drives & NAS

Choose an external drive with at least twice the capacity of the data you are backing up, from a known maker, and treat it as one copy rather than the whole plan. Apple gives the twice-your-Mac rule for Time Machine. Whether it is a hard drive or an SSD matters less than keeping a second copy elsewhere and testing a restore.

Three external hard drives of different sizes standing on a desk beside a coiled braided cable, with a NAS behind

Part of the guide: External Drives, SSDs and NAS: A Beginner's Guide

An external drive is the simplest first backup for a computer: plug it in, point the built-in tool at it, and you have a second copy. It is one part of the wider external drives, SSDs and NAS guide, and this page covers how to pick one without overspending or leaving gaps.

How big should the drive be?

Buy at least twice the capacity of the data you want to protect. Apple states that rule for Time Machine: use a disk with at least twice the storage capacity of your Mac. The spare room lets the backup keep earlier versions of files that changed.

Two points keep sizing honest:

Hard drive or SSD?

Either is fine for backups. The practical differences are cost, speed and handling.

Trait External hard drive External SSD
Cost per GB Usually lower Usually higher
Speed Slower, fine for overnight backups Faster, shorter first backup
Handling Moving parts, dislikes knocks No moving parts, better for carrying
Best for Large home archive kept at a desk Portable or frequently moved backups

We do not quote prices here because they change; check current listings from the maker. See the HDD vs SSD guide for the longer comparison.

Which tool will use it?

The operating system’s own tool is the easiest route.

  • Mac: Time Machine accepts a USB or Thunderbolt drive. Apple notes it may ask you to erase the disk, and you can optionally encrypt backups. See Time Machine step by step.
  • Windows 11: File History saves to an external drive or a network location, but only backs up libraries such as Documents, Pictures, Videos, Music and Desktop by default. See backing up a Windows PC.

Checked on 2026-11-14 against the Apple and Microsoft pages listed under sources.

Formatting and sharing between Mac and Windows

Back up first: if the drive already holds files you want, copy them elsewhere before letting any tool erase it, because erasing deletes what is on it. A drive used only by one computer can take whatever format the backup tool wants. If you must read it on both Mac and Windows, pick a format both understand; our drive formats guide compares the options.

Habits that matter more than the model

  1. Keep it dedicated. Apple recommends using a Time Machine disk only for backups.
  2. Eject before unplugging. Apple says to eject the drive or shut down the Mac before disconnecting.
  3. Encrypt if it travels. Time Machine offers optional encryption, which means a password is needed to restore.
  4. Test a restore. Open a few files from the backup now and then. A backup you have never restored is unproven.
  5. Keep a second copy. One drive beside the computer fails with the computer in a fire, flood or theft. Follow the 3-2-1 backup rule.

Which should you choose?

  • Mostly documents and photos on one PC: a mid-size hard drive at the twice-your-data rule, plus a cloud or off-site copy.
  • Laptop that travels: a portable SSD, with encryption, and a second copy at home.
  • Many devices or a family: consider a network drive; read what is a NAS first.

If a drive is already failing, clicking or disappearing, stop using it and contact the maker’s support or a qualified professional. GigaGone does not offer recovery help.

FAQ

How big should an external backup drive be?

Aim for at least twice the size of the data you are protecting. Apple states this rule for Time Machine, and it leaves room for older versions of changed files. Remember the label is in decimal units, so the drive shows slightly less in Windows. Our backup estimator helps you size it from your real photo, video and document totals.

Is an SSD or a hard drive better for backups?

Both work. Hard drives usually cost less per gigabyte, which suits large, rarely read archives. SSDs are quieter, faster and have no moving parts, which suits portable use. For either, check the maker’s own specification and warranty rather than assuming, and remember neither type removes the need for a second copy.

Can I use one drive for both backups and storing files?

It is better not to. Apple advises using a Time Machine disk only for Time Machine backups, because other files compete for space and the oldest backups are deleted when the disk fills. A separate drive for backups keeps the arrangement predictable and easier to restore from.

Should I leave the backup drive plugged in?

A permanently connected drive is convenient for automatic backups, but anything connected can be affected by the same fault, power surge or malware as your computer. Keeping one extra copy that is disconnected, or stored elsewhere, covers that gap. Eject the drive properly before unplugging it.

Do I need to format a new external drive first?

Often the backup tool handles it. Time Machine may ask to erase the drive during setup, and that deletes anything already on it, so move any files you want to keep first. Windows File History uses the drive as it is formatted. If you share a drive between Mac and Windows, choose a compatible format deliberately.

How long does an external drive last?

There is no fixed lifespan. Drives can fail at any age, which is why one drive is never a complete backup. Plan for a failure by keeping a second copy elsewhere, replacing the drive if it shows warning signs, and checking that you can restore files.

Sources

  1. Apple Support: Back up your Mac with Time Machine
  2. Microsoft Support: Backup and restore with File History
  3. Seagate Support: Why does my hard drive report less capacity than the label?

Questions readers ask

How big should an external backup drive be?

Aim for at least twice the size of the data you are protecting. Apple states this rule for Time Machine, and it leaves room for older versions of changed files. Remember the label is in decimal units, so the drive shows slightly less in Windows. Our backup estimator helps you size it from your real photo, video and document totals.

Is an SSD or a hard drive better for backups?

Both work. Hard drives usually cost less per gigabyte, which suits large, rarely read archives. SSDs are quieter, faster and have no moving parts, which suits portable use. For either, check the maker's own specification and warranty rather than assuming, and remember neither type removes the need for a second copy.

Can I use one drive for both backups and storing files?

It is better not to. Apple advises using a Time Machine disk only for Time Machine backups, because other files compete for space and the oldest backups are deleted when the disk fills. A separate drive for backups keeps the arrangement predictable and easier to restore from.

Should I leave the backup drive plugged in?

A permanently connected drive is convenient for automatic backups, but anything connected can be affected by the same fault, power surge or malware as your computer. Keeping one extra copy that is disconnected, or stored elsewhere, covers that gap. Eject the drive properly before unplugging it.

Do I need to format a new external drive first?

Often the backup tool handles it. Time Machine may ask to erase the drive during setup, and that deletes anything already on it, so move any files you want to keep first. Windows File History uses the drive as it is formatted. If you share a drive between Mac and Windows, choose a compatible format deliberately.

How long does an external drive last?

There is no fixed lifespan. Drives can fail at any age, which is why one drive is never a complete backup. Plan for a failure by keeping a second copy elsewhere, replacing the drive if it shows warning signs, and checking that you can restore files.

Further reading

  1. Apple Support: Back up your Mac with Time Machine (support.apple.com)
  2. Microsoft Support: Backup and restore with File History (support.microsoft.com)
  3. Seagate Support: Why does my hard drive report less capacity than the label? (seagate.com)

Worth reading next

Back to top